Portland Criminal Defense Cases We Handle
When an arrest happens, prosecutors begin building their case immediately. Their job is to present the strongest possible version of the evidence against you. Our job is to challenge that case at every stage: reviewing evidence for constitutional violations, identifying weaknesses in witness accounts, filing pretrial motions, negotiating charges, and taking the case to trial when that’s the right path. Early contact with a criminal defense attorney matters. Statements made to law enforcement before a lawyer is involved can shape the entire trajectory of a case.
We’ve represented clients the prosecution believed were indefensible. In one case involving a Class A Gross Sexual Assault charge, where the state openly said a defense win was impossible, the result was a hung jury. We treat hung juries, reduced charges, and dismissals as outcomes worth fighting for, because a conviction in Maine creates a permanent public record that follows a person into every job application, rental agreement, and licensing review that comes after.
Criminal defense cases we handle include:
We also draw on a network of investigators, forensic specialists, medical professionals, and financial experts when the facts demand it. Complex charges require more than legal argument; they require evidence that can withstand cross-examination.
Appeals Before Maine’s Highest Courts
A verdict isn’t always the end. Grounds for appeal can include legal errors at trial, prosecutorial misconduct, ineffective assistance of prior counsel, and newly discovered evidence. Maine imposes strict filing deadlines after a verdict, and missing that window typically forecloses the option entirely.
We handle felony and other criminal appeals before Maine’s Law Court, the First Circuit Court of Appeals, and the Supreme Court of the United States. We’ve successfully reversed criminal verdicts through the appellate process, and clients who need to pursue an appeal don’t have to start over with a new firm that doesn’t know their case.
How Tim Zerillo Approaches Criminal Defense
There’s a significant gap between understanding criminal law and knowing how to fight inside it. Tim Zerillo has spent his career narrowing that gap through both practice and scholarship. He’s the author of Defending Specific Crimes, published by James Publishing, and has written dozens of articles on criminal defense tactics. He teaches other lawyers advanced cross-examination techniques, digital evidence handling, and sentencing advocacy as a frequent national lecturer. The National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers named him a “Best of the Best” speaker in both 2022 and 2024, and he has chaired the organization’s Defending Modern Drug Cases seminar, most recently its 18th annual session. He’s also a past president of the Maine Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers and a recipient of that organization’s President’s Award.
That standing shapes how we build cases. We approach the Maine criminal system with a clear view of its structural problems, including overcharging and the risk of wrongful conviction, and we prepare accordingly. Trial preparation here means examining digital evidence and forensic reports, mapping cross-examination strategy, and building sentencing presentations that put a human face on what the numbers say. When we sit across from a prosecutor to negotiate, we’re doing it from a position of documented preparation, not one of hoping for a favorable offer.
Where Portland Criminal Cases Are Heard
Most criminal cases filed in Portland begin at the Cumberland County Unified Criminal Docket, which handles initial appearances, bail hearings, misdemeanor charges, and OUI cases. Felony indictments and jury trials are heard at Cumberland County Superior Court.
Each courtroom has its own procedural patterns, scheduling norms, and judicial expectations. Defense strategy that doesn’t account for the specific court where a case will be heard is incomplete strategy. Knowing what to expect from arraignment through pretrial motions and into trial lets clients make informed decisions at each stage rather than being caught off guard by how the process unfolds.
